Cher's daughter, Chastity Bono, recently came out as transgender. Now going by the name Chaz, he will be transitioning so that his female body matches with his gender identity.
While I'm impressed that most media sources are respectfully referring to Chaz using his preferred name and pronouns, public response to his transition has been terrifying. (See
TMZ article)
While acceptance of gays and lesbians is definitely on the rise, and gay marriage is legal in several states, the fight for transgender individuals lags behind.
Commenters argue that Chaz should not be called he because he is still, and will always be, a woman. They argue that Chaz will always have XX chromosomes. This point is true but irrelevant. Sex and gender are two separate things, and while Chaz does not deny that he is biologically female, he is the only person who can comment on his gender. Gender is complex and a matter of personal identity. Chaz has stated that he is a man, so why would anyone claim otherwise? And if he identifies as a man, and wants to be referred to as a man, why would anyone disrespect his wishes? Do heterosexual, non-transgender individuals somehow have a right to determine for themselves who counts as men and women?
Some claim that Chaz is transitioning because he is homophobic and doesn't want to be a lesbian. This idea is outrageous. Chaz obviously does not have a problem with lesbians - he came out as a lesbian in 1995 in The Advocate. That aside, why would anyone choose being transgender over being a lesbian unless they legitimately felt they were a man? Transgender individuals are well aware that they will be ostracized, discriminated against, and called freaks. Chaz's decision to come out as transgender has resulted in countless nasty comments and negative attention. Instead of looking for excuses, people should accept Chaz's identity.
Even more illogical are the many comments stating that (despite Chaz's claim that he will remain with his girlfriend during and after transitioning) Chaz's girlfriend, Jennifer, is a lesbian and therefore will not be interested in Chaz anymore. How come anyone feels they know more about her sexual preferences and desires than she does? Sexuality can be fluid, and one's sexual preferences are shaped by more than just genitals.
People should stop putting a box around Chaz and other transgender individuals. Calling him "it" is denying any sort of human decency. The inhumane responses to his courageous decision to come out of the closet are pathetic.